Kitsuragi Keima (The World God Only Knows) v. Rito Yuuki (To Love Ru)
Let's try something a little different this time around. Both of these guys would lose a fight before the first punch is thrown. However, for various reasons, they both have a harem that would impress any ancient sultan. So, who is the better ladies man? You decide.
P.S. Not the best examples of their work here, but you probably aren't posting unless you are familiar with one or both shows anyway, right?
Keima Is A Better "Ladies Man" Based On The Fact That He Has Experience From "H" Games, However Rito Has No Experience Whats So Ever And His And Gets Shy When He Tries To Talk To Haruna But His Harem Is Accidental. There Naturally Attracted To Him (Which He Doesn't Even Notice)
You're kind of comparing an apple to an orange. While both are in unwanted harems, that's really the only thing they have in common. Since Kami Nomi zo Shiru Sekai is a MUCH better manga, I'll go with Keima, but again, apple and an orange here.
@hellfiredragon9 You may have a point, but, you could boil it down to which is the better archetype. The natural, or the player (pun intended) who goes after girls knowingly. Ultimately, I say this match goes to Rito. It's not exactly a fair fight though. Keima draws 'em in one at a time. Rito can bag 'em in groups.
If we consider these two are like an apple and orange though, how bout Rito v. Kamijiou Touma from Toaru Majutsu no Index? Or Kosaka Junpei from Nyan Koi? Touma actually roped a nun of all things, and Junpei's charm doesn't even stop with human beings :p